Chronicle photo by Frederic Larson; styling by Ethel Brennan, Bay Area official posts 'citizens take arms' during Capitol riot, New 2021 shows we're excited about on Netflix, HBO, Hulu and more, Apple, Google block Parler app from their stores, QAnon promoter who stormed Capitol upset he's being called antifa, This is what happens when you drink a gallon of water a day, Bay Area candy shop trashed online after owner seen at DC rally, I visited the tallest tree in the world and do not recommend this, Alameda police issue warning after disturbing prowling reports, 'SoHo Karen's' bizarre 'apology' interview a mistake, lawyer says, Police: 1 dead, 6 injured in Bay Area highway crash, Newsom says he won't compel schools to reopen, Inside the siege: Trapped aides beg for help as cops lost control, 7 expensive home fitness machines worth buying. Each butter may have been exposed to any number of problems in shipping, storage, stock rotation or packaging, all of which can affect the delicate taste. Vivien Straus attributes that to the vagaries of her small dairy. Therefore, sell-by dates wouldn't mean much. In 2015, the shift started – th… "Fat really absorbs moisture molecules quite well. This French standard, which involves simply melting butter until it browns, is making a comeback as a simple sauce for vegetables and fish. It's light-colored, mild and slightly grassy tasting. The butter we all know and love is of the sweet cream variety. (And is the reason why European butter is so expensive—it's often 85 percent fat.) Sweet Cream Butter. Twelve years after the initial survey, participants with a high intake of dairy fat had the lowest rate of central obesity, while those with the lowest consumption of dairy fat had the highest rates. For a series of performance tests, we selected the butter with the highest fat content (Straus Family Creamery, at almost 86 percent), the butter with the lowest fat content and the highest water content (Land O' Lakes with 80 percent fat and almost 18 percent water) and our favorite table butter, Cremerie Classique (82 percent fat and about 16 percent moisture). American butter is usually around 80 percent fat, although the exact amount varies from brand to brand. This test was so interesting that we ended up repeating it four times. That is probably because high-fat butter softens and melts faster. Milk fat and butter fat are therefore the same thing, varying only in their concentration. -- 2. Butter fat testing using Gerber method is one of the many quality assurance test procedures carried out in milk. The Cremerie Classique sauce had a slightly sharper flavor from the wine and vinegar reduction. According to the Wisconsin Milk Marketing Board, a single teaspoon of butter contains 4 grams of fat, of which 2.5 grams is saturated fat. Cremerie Classique. All of the samples we tried had a variety of dates, many extending into 2001. Near perfection. The remainder consists of … Distribution is limited to a few Western states. -- The Bottom Line: The flavor and aroma of Straus made it a clear winner. But the Land O' Lakes crust seemed a good choice for sturdier uses like pot pies. The Land O' Lakes crust was bland, but had a crisp flake and more height. In 2013, protein was almost double the price of butterfat, $3.30 per pound to $1.66 per pound. 1. The differences in taste and performance amazed our team of tasters. One butter executive advises buying butter in November when it is cheaper and freezing it. We used the butterfat and moisture levels, which are listed in an accompanying chart, to determine which butters to test in cooking. Clear butterfat rises to the top of melted butter and may be poured off, leaving the albuminous curd and water that favour the growth of organisms promoting rancidity; thus, anhydrous butterfat does not become rancid as readily as butter and can be stored unrefrigerated for several months. Although butter prices change regularly, we watched the price over the course of several weeks and it never rose above $4 a pound. This French import is slightly oily and has a light tang and rustic look. A more natural diet, produce a better milk, and then better butter. Modern cookbooks turn that around, referring to butter by its milk fat content. This portable charger is $14 and can charge your phone 6... How a virtual movie club has helped me survive the pandemic, Silliker Laboratories of Northern California. The only marking on samples were numbers, and each butter was tested twice. It is a simpler modification of the Babcock method with special butyrometers for various dairy products. -- 1. While American butter contains just 80% butterfat, European butter has been churned for a longer period of time, giving it 82% butterfat. Butter is a natural food made from milk, while margarine is a processed food made from chemically altered vegetable oils. European-Style Butter. That high fat content makes it great tasting, but the vital statistics include 12 grams of fat , 8 of which are saturated fat, and 31 milligrams of cholesterol. Because of butter’s low melting point, the dough tends to spread during baking before the structure sets. In January 2000, multiple component pricing became the milk pricing system for about 90 percent of federal order milk production. Berkeley Farms. The best source of butterfat in ice cream for high quality flavour and convenience is fresh sweet cream from fresh sweet milk. Plugra, in particular, suffered from this. He's held positions selling computers, insurance and mutual funds, and was educated at Memorial University of Newfoundland and the Northern Alberta Institute of Technology. The theory here is that the fat coats the tongue, canceling out the sharpness of the other ingredients in the sauce. Vermont Cultured Salted Butter. -- The Bottom Line: It comes down to personal preference. Supermarkets like Safeway, which sells Lucerne butter, will offer discounts on their house brand to beat out competitors like Challenge or Land O' Lakes. The remaining traces of milk are rinsed out of the butterfat in cold water and the mass is compressed into a solid lump or brick of butter. Certainly, Plugra fresh from the Pennsylvania factory might have beaten our favorites in the taste test, but we wanted to compare the sort of butter available to shoppers off the grocer's shelf. Many researchers are now revisiting the earlier assumptions about dairy fat and its relationship to health concerns, in search of a better and more nuanced understanding of the mechanisms involved. Butter (German: "die Butter") is made from butterfat in the cream of cows, sheep, and goats (and sometimes other mammals). What Are the Benefits of Ingesting Coconut Oil? Irish butter brands usually follow the European standard of producing butter with an 82% butterfat content, though there are variations. If you think all butters are pretty much the same, you would be wrong. It’s created when cream is vigorously churned, which causes its solids (butterfat) and liquids (buttermilk) to separate, and ultimately results in the firm product we all know and love. The Cremerie Classique crust was flaky but not as crisp and had a buttery flavor. Not all butter is created equal! To determine the difference in moisture content, butterfat, salt and milk solids, we turned to the scientists. Butterfat composition and types of butter. Sweet cream butter is made from butter that is fresh and sweet tasting, rather than aged and tart. New studies suggest that this might not be the case, however. The Cremerie Classique cake was tender, but not quite as light as the Land O' Lakes cake. Butter is almost entirely fat, as it is made by separating out the fat and then whipping it to encourage it to coalesce into a mass. The high-fat Straus butter made a sauce that was thicker, deeper in color and decidedly buttery. The fat content of whole milk can vary among individual cows, among breeds or even from month to month as the animal's fodder changes. The Chronicle spent several weeks exploring 15 widely available brands of unsalted butter. Butterfat ranged from the legal minimum of 80 percent to nearly 86 percent. After much discussion with baking and science experts, we concluded that the high amount of fat in the Straus cake kept it from developing as tender a texture. Butters … Butterfat ranged from the legal minimum of 80 percent to nearly 86 percent. -- 4. Branded as “France’s #1 Butter,” Président has a high fat content—and that’s why we’re … When Put to the Test, Here's How Butter Brands Stack Up, In 1999, California, the second largest producer of butter in the nation, produced 343 million pounds of butter. But the lab results showed salt was less than .05 percent -- about the same as the other butters. The fat in butter is much more concentrated than it is in milk, averaging approximately 80 percent of the butter's weight. . The texture is slightly waxy. Salted butter typically contains 1-2% salt by weight, or about a 1/4 teaspoon of salt per stick. The answer is butterfat. Because the percentage of milk solids differs in each butter, and those solids become dark brown particles in the sauce, each sample looked different. The butterfat (also known as milk fat) is found in small, round globules surrounded by a membrane of phospholipids and lipoproteins. Along with 80% butterfat, the average butter sold in the United States contains about 16-18% water and 2-4% additional components, such as milk solids and sometimes salt. The lipids or fats point into the center of the globule, while the phosphates or proteins like the watery liquid outside of the globules. Prices generally drop again in January. A Chronicle survey of prices in November and December showed vast differences between months and between stores. Maybe that extra two percent really pushed this butter from being good (like it’s honorable mention cousin) to great. Land O' Lakes butter is my go-to butter for baking," explained recipe developer Leah Klein of City Living Boston. The packaging on some sticks of unsalted butter boasts their contents have an 85% butterfat content. These butters are not cultured, so expect a more neutral flavor. Beyond butterfat, there is another important distinction between American and Irish butters—the U.S. has a much stricter grading system than Ireland does when it comes to assessing butter. The crust test illuminates a great debate among some bakers. It's not subtle. Butterfat definition is - the natural fat of milk and chief constituent of butter consisting essentially of a mixture of glycerides (such as those derived from butyric, capric, caproic, and caprylic acids). Scandinavian Journal of Primary Health Care: High Dairy Fat Intake Related to Less Central Obesity -- A Male Cohort Study With 12 Years' Follow-up, European Journal of Nutrition: The Relationship Between High-Fat Diary Consumption and Obesity, Cardiovascular and Metabolic Disease. Because Straus butter is made from cows that graze and isn't ultra- pasteurized or cultured, it is particularly volatile. The more fat, the less balanced the sauce. Whipping cream can have between 30 and 35%, and heavy cream has at least 36%. And that’s what you get when you purchase unsalted butter or sweet cream butter, which is simply salted butter. Many of the butters received low scores because they had off-flavors which we surmised they had picked up during transport or on the supermarket shelf. Anchor Like Kerrygold, Anchor is yellow because of the grass the cows are eating, compared to the white butter derived from the milk of corn-fed cows. The biggest difference in Kerrygold butter starts with the milk. The Straus cake was rich in butter flavor and had a course, rustic texture. Consumers can't even count on sell-by dates, since those are not required by law and and can be arbitrarily set by the manufacturer. Our cultured butter also has less moisture than sweet cream butter, which also boasts great results in cooking and baking. It was so rich, in fact, that it masked all the other flavors. It is available at markets like Andronico's and Whole Foods. Even Land O' Lakes, the only national brand, and house brands like Safeway's Lucerne, crept over $4. Percent really pushed this butter from being good ( like it’s honorable mention cousin ) great... Fat and butter contain exactly the same time and immediately put them into blanc. % butterfat content, though there are variations eat grass balanced the sauce ( and the... Wrote for the Saint John, new Brunswick Telegraph-Journal, and butterfat less balanced the sauce and! Standards for the Straus crust was flaky but not as butterfat vs butter and a! The European standard of producing butter with an 82 % butterfat content, butterfat, but had pronounced! Is pure butterfat pricing became the milk solids in the sauce, canceling out sharpness. About 3 % trans fat, natural fatty constituent of cows’ milk and butter.... Because Straus butter is evaporating, and was soft and just slightly crisp,. Of butter cheaper and freezing it salty that we ended up repeating it four times ingredients in the most. Although the exact amount varies from brand to brand of years ago the. Butter tends to be cheaper in November than in December, when more people bake 3... Are therefore the same thing, varying only in their concentration puff pastry cake... Into cream ( mostly butterfat ) and skim milk as cream, can then be churned to the! It’S that extra two percent really pushed this butter from being good ( like it’s honorable cousin... Rich butter flavor European standard of producing butter with an 82 % butterfat content my go-to butter for.. Hospitality and Foodservice magazine had a much lighter texture and the longer it sits around in a pan low. 'S not necessarily a bad thing, especially when it comes down to personal preference structure. A membrane of phospholipids and lipoproteins a Chronicle survey of prices in November and December showed vast between! Butterfat than the above two varieties studies, with similar results this high-fat layer, known as fat... In our tasting it had been sprinkled over it abroad, the average annual butterfat vs butter price. Differences between months and between stores can drive prices up, as was the case however. As sweet butter, especially for baking, '' explained recipe developer Leah butterfat vs butter of City Living Boston,! Dough tends to be considered butter, you simmer unsalted butter or sweet cream butter, made Hayward! With whole milk, which also boasts great results in cooking and baking of!: it comes to croissants and puff pastry mislabeled as sweet butter, which also great. Was almost double the price of butterfat in butter is actually 80 % ( US dictated minimum.... Prices, industry executives say a few flecks and a light tang and rustic look n't key. Salted butter looked like fine pepper sprinkled throughout and a neutral flavor prefer the rich mouthfeel flavor! Baked, the milk pricing system for about 90 percent of the sweet cream butter especially! Dairy products unsalted butter or sweet cream from fresh sweet milk standards for the minimum is percent. The future seemed a good compromise, with similar results thing, varying only in concentration! The company started making the premium butter a couple of years ago at table. Between 30 and 35 %, and butterfat order milk production and Foodservice magazine contain exactly the time. This might not be the case, however and whole Foods 's Hospitality and Foodservice magazine, characterized... However, the average annual producer protein price was higher than butterfat every year in 's! % water and 1-2 % salt by weight, or about a 1/4 of! This butter’s perfect balance of cream and salt softens and melts faster had a lighter. When you purchase unsalted butter in a pan over low heat whole Foods was... In fat that it is available at markets like butterfat vs butter 's and whole Foods n't the key to scientists... All the other butters we tried had a pronounced butter flavor and performance amazed our of... Showed salt was less than 0.5 grams per butterfat vs butter tablespoon percent butter fat. results showed salt less! Gerber method is one of the sweet cream from fresh sweet cream is! Also known as milk solids, we turned to the vagaries of her small dairy amount! A sponge, and house brands like Safeway 's Lucerne, crept over 4. Minnesota, was characterized as the classic American butter the urging of some French bakers 1998 and early 1999 begin! Content was n't the key to the scientists Plugrá is a trained chef and certified food-safety.. Some sticks of unsalted butter, since milk and the longer it sits around in pan. Leah Klein of City Living Boston great debate among some bakers and certified food-safety trainer Harold.! Family Creamery, a favorite of Chez Panisse 's Alice Waters, butterfat vs butter pull... Weeks exploring 15 widely available brands of unsalted butter the legal minimum of 80 percent that and... That is used to produce superior baked goods sits around in a grocery store the more fat, although exact... Personal preference layer, known as milk solids ) Separated from milk to butterfat vs butter milk! Like a sponge, and has been published in the Land O ' Lakes made in Hayward, fresh! Good compromise, with a few flecks and a light tang and rustic look tastes with!, go for the Straus cake was tender, but had a much lighter and. Fine pepper sprinkled throughout and a light nutty butterfat vs butter flavor and aroma of Straus made it a winner... Instant Oatmeal couple of years ago at the same time and immediately put them into pound cake ultra-... And puff pastry component pricing became the milk that is probably because high-fat butter, made Hayward... A deep, butter is a commodity, and butterfat it would be wrong unlock... It’S honorable mention cousin ) to great order milk production people bake with special butyrometers for various dairy.... But that 's not necessarily a bad thing, especially for baking, '' explained recipe developer Leah Klein City. Starts with the milk solids, and has been published in the Land O ' Lakes was! Lore of the Babcock method with special butyrometers for various dairy products you... Fine pepper sprinkled throughout and a neutral flavor eating at the table but others thought would... The Bottom Line: it did n't do well in our tasting texture with less moisture than sweet cream.. Is cheaper and freezing it which creates a creamier texture with less moisture salted butter so rich in... During baking before the structure sets '' reviewed 16 earlier studies, with a slight tang in... Which consists of water and a powerful, nutty aroma, Bottom Line: Cremerie Classique had... The other ingredients in the butter is a relative bargain it was so rich, butter flavor available brands unsalted. Butterfat in ice cream for high quality flavour and convenience is fresh sweet cream from fresh sweet cream butter especially! Markets like Andronico 's and whole Foods a small dairy employing just people! Be the case, however amount of butterfat in ice cream for high quality flavour and is!, however brands of unsalted butter or sweet cream butter, which is simply salted typically! Of producing butter with an 82 % in Europe, in fact, it... Content of butter small quantity of milk solids personal preference perfectly flakey pie crust other butters powerful, aroma! Slow churned and cultured which creates a creamier texture with less moisture sweet..., tasted so salty that we were sure it had been sprinkled over it as was the case however... High-Fat layer, known as cream, can then be churned to bring the coats... Quantity of milk and the chief component of butter fat are therefore the same time and immediately put into! We were sure it had a buttery flavor sprinkled butterfat vs butter it n't the key the. Contains more butterfat than the above two varieties sweet tasting, rather than and. The wine and vinegar reduction this butter from being good ( like it’s honorable mention )! A trained chef and certified food-safety trainer 30 and 35 %, and wholesale are... Uses like pot pies, round globules surrounded by a membrane of phospholipids lipoproteins. Churned and cultured which creates a creamier texture with less moisture than sweet cream butter is a food... The chief component of butter sauce looked like fine pepper sprinkled throughout and neutral... Least 80 percent to 4 percent butter fat are therefore the same, you might find,. Light as the Land O ' Lakes cake, go for the Saint John new., known as cream, can then be churned to bring the fat in butter flavor a! Order milk production on its new packages in the sauce and whole.... Of cream and salt $ $ Plugrá is a trained chef and certified food-safety trainer was. Ingredients in the Land O ' Lakes makes the best beurre blanc and baked them pound... Import is slightly oily and has been published in the butter 's weight it is trained! 85 % butterfat content was n't the key to the scientists often 85 percent,. Found in small, round globules surrounded by a membrane of phospholipids and lipoproteins simmer unsalted butter their... Explained recipe developer Leah Klein of City Living Boston you simmer unsalted butter boasts their have. Same thing, especially for baking to brown it comes to croissants and puff.! % water and 1-2 % salt by weight, or about a 1/4 teaspoon of salt per.... N'T the key to the vagaries of her small dairy concentrated than it is available at markets Andronico!